Posts Tagged ‘abraham’

Rubedo – The Missing Wisdom of the Feminine – Part II

November 20, 2026

The stories of “now”

You would think that society has always understood that rape is a crime, the victim deserves respectful treatment, and that justice is always served. But that has rarely been the case. And the fight for those things only really got started in the 1970s.

About that time, several groundbreaking books and essays began to appear, arguing against the prevailing methods of handling sexual trauma cases. One book in particular, Against Our Will: Men, Women and Rape by Susan Brownmiller, examined the topic from a broad historical and legal perspective and stated the premise that rape is “a conscious process of intimidation by which all men keep all women in a state of fear.”

While Brownmiller’s book has been criticized for some of her conclusions, most especially for how she covered the subjects of race and rape, that book, along with a few others, triggered a bigger fight to change the public outlook and attitudes about rape. Some of the especially important efforts focused on fighting:

  • The requirement for a corroborating witness to the rape
  • Allowing defense attorneys to introduce evidence of a victim’s past sexual history in a trial
  • The belief that women who were raped deserved it

So this means those battles fixed the problems and it’s all better now, right? A current scan of news headlines demonstrates the exact opposite.

One recent news article mentioned a police chief in another state who’d had several domestic violence arrests over as many years, along with charges for disorderly conduct, violation of protective orders, and giving false statements. And even though he completed a mandated Family Violence Education Program after a previous arrest to avoid conviction, here he was again, charged with another domestic violence episode. Was he convicted this time? No. The current charge was reduced to creating a public disturbance. His penalty? A $75 fine. For a man with his criminal record, and who put his hands around the woman’s throat, that’s all society thought he had to do.

And the New York Times did a recent in-depth article on “How Jeffrey Epstein Grew His Sex-Trafficking Ring.” Now, in 2026, it is clear how little law enforcement and the public yet understand about the vulnerability of victims, especially ones targeted at a young age.

Instead of blaming the man himself, it revealed how vulnerable teens were viewed as criminals themselves once they hit eighteen. They were vulnerable teens struggling to even find a place to live or money for food. Epstein targeted them, luring them with attention and empathy, and giving them money for rent and food. Bit by bit, he slowly got them to do “more and more for him.” While they initially resisted, the confusing mix of love, attention, guilt, and a sense of indebtedness to him for his caring became the slippery slope that ensnared them in his abuse.

At the same time, he encouraged them to bring friends. Knowing other vulnerable teens who were barely surviving, they thought they were doing those friends a favor to introduce them to Epstein. Yet later, they were viewed as “traffickers,” especially if during that process they turned eighteen. It was as if hitting eighteen was this magic “adulthood” button, and they were suddenly astute and aware of what was being done to them instead of emotionally battered and beaten kids.

How does a culture even consider that person to be a trafficker when they have been used, abused, and traumatized themselves? And when they are targeted because they are hungry or homeless? THIS is what happens in a patriarchal culture where, instead of ensuring people have food to eat, kids are cared for, and resources are provided to solve homelessness, they are instead abandoned by society, then blamed. What if instead, our culture took the matriarchal approach of feeding and nurturing, making sure no one was abandoned to die on the streets? How much different would our society be?

And I won’t even delve into the sexual assault by Brock Turner, who attempted to rape an unconscious, intoxicated young woman and was only stopped by two men passing by. He received a six-month sentence in prison, served three months, and was released for good behavior. Such a light sentence caused such a public outcry that, in a recall election, the judge was removed. While it feels like justice because the judge was eventually removed, that doesn’t address why he felt it was okay to assault the woman, that the judge gave a light sentence to not ruin Turner’s life, and that she carries that pain with her the rest of her life while he goes on with his.

So, with these headlines still screaming out stories of abuse, violence, incest, and victimization, it is clear our society has a long way to go.

The stories of “then”

Long before any victim might become a fighter or a warrior for legal justice, first they have to get help. Heal. Become “whole again.”

Even if they never are able to become that crusading legal warrior against injustice, and that is more often the case, they need to be their own spiritual warrior and healer. They have to rest. Recover. Rebuild. Learn to accept they are worthy. Not alone. Not trash. And most of all, NOT TO BLAME.

I can’t speak for anyone else’s way to navigate those struggles or find answers. But for me, this is where my list of divine women and mythological characters came in. This is where their stories helped me not to give up, not to feel alone in my struggles, and to offset the damage of things done to me. By focusing on their stories and any lessons in them, I could block out the effects of the stories that still show up every day in the news. Because if I can’t restore myself and restore my hope in life, I can’t do anything about what’s going on “out there.”

What those stories can give…and how to access it

The stories and characters I connect with aren’t just frivolous diversions. They aren’t tales of escapism and fun. But they are tales of women…women stuck in all kinds of desperate situations, confronting things they have no power over, yet strive to somehow carve out whatever power they can.

The story of the queen, Clytemnestra? She was the emotionally broken mother who had to watch her husband sacrifice her daughter so the gods would bless his war against Troy. And during that war, she plotted how to exact revenge for her daughter by killing her husband. That is not a light-hearted bedtime story. And maybe not the best solution. But the story of her agony and evolution to that decision reveals what trauma can do to a person.

And then there’s Margaret Atwood’s novel, The Penelopiad. It told the story of the Odyssey from the perspective of the women – Odysseus’ long-suffering wife struggling to hold onto her world; and of the slave women, who had no rights or power and who were first taken by the freeloading men in the household, then ultimately killed by Odysseus for bringing dishonor on his house. Neither had any say in their paths. They were just trying to survive when the deck was stacked against them.

These are tales of agony and death. Tragedy and sometimes ultimate failure. But these are scenarios also seen in the present. The stories are removed enough from the present to be called fiction. But they are mirrors of our present day.

What does a woman do now, when she is tormented and abused, raped by her husband, and powerless to stop him from harming their kids? What happens to someone in our society when, pushed to the limit, they take justice into their own hands…possibly the only justice they feel is possible?

So I learn by reading the stories. I identify with the characters and their sense of powerlessness, and recognize I am not the first or the only one to be in that position. In some small way, I feel less shame. The stories let me know that I wasn’t the only one who was trapped and lacked power. They show me that another person — an author — also thought about what it is like to be at your wits’ end and have to do whatever you need to in order to survive…even if it is shameful.

And I seek answers to questions like: What did the heroine do? Did she succeed? Was it the right choice? In the end, was there any justice or peace? As I question and analyze, I evaluate whether anything was useful, good, or bad.

Then there is the other type of story question – called “Midrash.” It is the question of what is the story behind the story. What was going on in the background that set up the story, that we aren’t told.

In a way, Midrash is more of a “conversation” with yourself, a back and forth of “what if” scenarios that might explain why the story was the way it was. If you do that with a fiction story, you can then learn to do that with your life.

The Midrash examples

Between the Bible and Greek mythology, there are so many stories that leave a person shaking their head and wondering if there wasn’t a much different, REAL story behind the one we are told.

Did anyone who read the Odyssey ever stop to wonder why Circe was alone on an island? Ask if she was lonely? Punished? Abused? Was she in despair?

Author Margaret Miller did. In her book, Circe, she crafted the midrash, the story behind the character. Miller thought deeply about who that goddess was and how she might have come to be there on that island. Then she created the backstory of an eternal goddess who wasn’t loved, but instead, manipulated and used. Of a girl who longed to be appreciated and valued, but was instead ridiculed. And then, as a punishment, she was exiled forever to the island. All because she got upset one day and used her “witching powers” – powers she didn’t even know she had – to get back at another. A normal sense of rage at poor treatment. Something any of us might have done. And lastly, it is the story of a woman, alone, who slowly carves out her own self-respect and healing, and who comes to know what she is really worth. It is a woman who learns lessons, finds love, and alters her outcome because of her own choices for happiness.

Then there is Eve. The villain of the Genesis story. The woman blamed for getting all of humanity thrown out of a life in the Garden of Eden. But was she the villain? What if God was hoping SOMEONE would WANT to question their existence? Would want to know what more there was to life and what it all meant? Adam was content to lounge in paradise. But what is paradise for? To spend an eternity just lying around, and never questioning any of it? Could it be that it was Eve who was doing God’s will to step up and ASK and SEEK? And how do we know that God’s instruction was NOT to eat the fruit of the tree? Did the story’s author change the details to make her the “bad guy?” Maybe God told him to do it, and Adam couldn’t be bothered.

And then there is Eve’s counterpart in Greek mythology – Pandora. Pandora was told not to open the box in her care, but she did. She wanted to know more. Explore. When men set sail into the unknown to explore, they are heralded as adventurers. Intrepid and courageous souls. So why is it that a woman shows those same qualities and she is decried as a villain?

In the story, they claim she released all kinds of calamities on the world when she opened the box. Were they calamities? How do we know? Our source is the men of antiquity who told the story. Could it be she released amazing wonders, and then men felt foolish for not having the courage to look in the box themselves? So out of jealousy and shame and fear, they changed the story?

Were men so afraid of women who showed curiosity and an adventurous spirit that they had to put them down and make them out to be untrustworthy, something to be controlled at all costs? That certainly seemed to be the case in the myth of Medusa.

She was a beautiful woman turned into a monster by the goddess Athena. Medusa was given live snakes for hair, and anyone who looked at her immediately was turned to stone. This was Medusa’s punishment for being raped by the god Poseidon in Athena’s temple. Later, the demigod Perseus was sent to behead Medusa. Several gods, including Athena, provided him with tools and assistance in this endeavor. And when Perseus returned with Medusa’s head, Athena placed the visage on her shield.

WHY did Athena punish Medusa instead of going after Poseidon? Why was Perseus considered heroic for killing Medusa? And why did so many of the Greek gods help Perseus instead of Medusa, who had been wronged?

There are so many things wrong with this story that you have to wonder what the ORIGINAL version was. What REALLY happened that someone would victim-blame Medusa?

After all, who would create a story that harmed a woman, then punished her for being harmed? But then, that same scenario appears in the news every day.

Sarah

Probably the one story I most wonder about and have questioned myself to death over is the tale where Abraham is told by God to sacrifice his only child, Isaac. The story says God was testing Abraham. WAS God actually doing that?

And was the story really more about Sarah, because Abraham failed to consult her? Or because he did, and Sarah practically tore his head off when he told her he was going to kill their son because a voice told him so? I can just imagine any mother’s reaction if their husband came to them with that line.

Think about it. So he got a “message from God” to sacrifice his son. At that moment, he had three choices: Question his sanity and ignore it. Check with the helpmate God gave him, i.e., Sarah, and get a second opinion. Or believe that he knew it all, and of course he must follow the voice as a test from God.

He obviously didn’t choose the first one, or the story would have ended there. And we know that in the Bible, it’s written that he picked the third choice.

But was that the actual story? Did he actually talk to Sarah and she hit the roof? Did he NOT talk to her and assume he knew best, and afterward she hit the roof?

If he talked to Sarah, I can just imagine her reaction:

“Are you crazy, old man?!!! Are you a demented old fool?! You hear ‘a voice,’ and you are convinced it’s God? What kind of God tells you to kill your son???!!!!”

Or maybe Abraham never went to Sarah because he knew she would stop him. No woman who ever carried a child and gave birth and nurtured would ever have agreed to a demand like that. As far as she was concerned, that voice was no God she would follow. And then, later, when she found out what he had done, that finished it with them. She would never trust, love, or be with him again.

Could the story have been that God’s real test of Abraham was to see if he would just blindly obey and not stop to THINK and QUESTION that command? Could it be that God was waiting to see if Abraham would consult his helpmate, deeply think this through, and share in the decision of what to do?

Whatever the original story, maybe the tale was rewritten to make Abraham heroic instead of an old fool and embarrass him?

I could imagine a God of love saying:

“I gave you a helpmate, and you didn’t even check with her? Talk it out and THINK this through? I gave you a son, and you would kill him without a second thought? You get a thought like that in your head and just think you are the only one who knows best about what to do? You never even questioned it???? Don’t you understand that the REAL answers come out of struggle, wrestling, thinking?”

In my own marriage, our true strength has always been the synergy of us working together. That collaboration has always resulted in the best answer because the right answer to anything was always somewhere between us. We have to chew on it, discuss and argue the merits and pitfalls, really struggle, to get to the place with the best answer.

And when I worked on an ethics board to protect people in research studies, it was the same. I would review the study documents, then decide what I thought should happen. But many times, when I met with the rest of the board to vote, our twelve minds brought a different, better outcome. From struggle came consensus for the best possible way. Twelve minds. Not one.

So in the story of Abraham and Isaac, maybe God expected that Abraham WOULD go to Sarah, and together they would make the right choice. But then instead, a surprised God had to actually intervene and send angels from heaven to stop him?

Are we willing to look deeper?

Could it be that the original story was about God trying to teach man the fallibility and dangers of trusting only his ego and brain, and how important it was to bring BOTH male and female together? Not blind obedience, but add in the woman’s powers of the heart, empathy, vulnerability, and compassion to thwart man’s “either/or” win/lose, winner-takes-all mentality?

So we are left to wonder: Was the story rewritten to let Abraham save face and look heroic? Or…was the story an ironic tale of a deed so outlandish that any reader would, of course, know it was a PARODY because who in their right mind would have done what Abraham did?

The point to all these examples, the bottom line, is the need for THINKING. QUESTIONING. WRESTLING WITH SOMETHING to get to the best answer. And the need for the power of BOTH sides of us, male and female. If only one or the other takes charge, what tragedy results?

And this doesn’t just apply to ancient stories. While Abraham didn’t bother to think or question “that voice” in his mind…do we bother to think or question in our lives when we read the news or when we hear what another tells us?

Maybe in life, as in mythology and Bible stories, the REAL truth is buried in the Midrash approach — read the story, then ask yourself what AREN’T we being told. And is there more to the story than appears on the surface? Maybe God is waiting to see if we will do the true work of digging it out.

Is there precedent for wondering if man changed the story?

So I’ve posed a lot of conjecture and questions. Someone might think I’ve lost it. OR they might think I am wrong in not accepting those old stories at face value because, of course, we all know that what was written in those stories was the TRUTH. But was it?

First, there is simply human error. There are numerous researchers who have spent careers questioning the translations and interpretations of the New Testament passages. And one of the first things they bring up is just the fallibility of human translators — meaning that there could be mistranslations, misspellings, errors in copying from previous editions. Any mistake made two thousand years ago and repeated, or compounded over the centuries, drastically changes the story and its meaning.

And then there is the question of changes made to serve the interests of the men at that time. Is there any evidence for that? Yes.

One of the researchers, theologian Elisabeth Schüssler Fiorenza, earned her doctorate in New Testament and early Christian studies and spent her life delving into the nature of women’s roles in the early church.

In her 1983 book, In Memory of Her, she noted how women had funded Jesus’ work, traveled with him, hosted gatherings, and served as leaders in the early church. Yet over time, the stories were changed. Women and their roles were excluded or handed over to men. Why?

And over those centuries, it was men who wrote and translated the Bible passages, and even decided which passages would be allowed into newer versions of the Bible. They chose to exclude several books that presented a different viewpoint. So her book and her work raised the questions I and others have raised: “Where are the women? Where did they go?”

And I’ll add three more questions:

  • What happens in our society when those women’s voices are lost?
  • What happens to all of us when the power of the feminine is excluded?
  • And what exactly IS the power of the feminine?

Up next

What about the women?

Painting by author

Note:

I am seeking financial support to complete my memoir, work with an editor, and make a visit to my home state for fact-checking. Your help would mean the world to me as I take this step toward healing and giving voice to my journey.

Please like, comment, and share this post to help spread the word. The link for my fundraiser is on GoFundMe. Thank you for your support.